The extraordinary Brothers Quay
Stephen and Timothy Quay by James Rose Based in the UK, James Rose is a freelance writer specialising in contemporary science fiction and horror cinema. | |
Where the dust has settled: The Brothers Quay
The Quays were once asked by poet J.D. McClatchy for a biography. As is typical of all of their responses to such questions, the brothers' initial reply coyly played with the myth they had, perhaps, generated for themselves by stating that each has one atrophied testicle and a sly liking for geese (2).What happens in the shadow, in the grey regions, also interests us – all that is elusive and fugitive, all that can be said in those beautiful half tones, or in whispers, in deep shade. (1)
– The Brothers Quay
When reading through the many critiques, articles and interviews concerning the Quays one fact becomes readily apparent: like all of their artistic output – filmic or otherwise – these identical twins are an enigma. The persona projected within these texts can be read as one that is as complex and nearly as mythical as their animated films. Emphasis is equally balanced between absurdities (such as the brothers often finishing each other's sentences and that they sign their correspondence simply with a 'Q') and the master craftsmanship of their imagery. Like their response to McClatchy's request, the Quays present to the viewer a highly personal world that is simultaneously believable but so obviously a myth.
As if to consolidate this contradiction, the Quays continued their reply to McClatchy by providing a biography that implied they would, by heredity alone, become animators:
Beginning their formal art education at the Philadelphia College of Art, both brothers specialised in illustration. Graduating in 1969, the Quays moved to Great Britain and enrolled at The Royal College of Art, London, in order to continue their training as illustrators and, by this time, filmmaking. Whilst at the RCA the brothers met Keith Griffiths who, since the successful completion of their first film, Nocturna Artificialia (1979), has been their producer and co-founder of their studio Atelier Koninck.
Nocturna Artificialia |
Although the narrative of Nocturna Artificialia is relatively easy to understand, as the Quays developed, their narratives became increasingly abstract. Their animations functioned on a much more visual and associative level, carefully grafting meaning into the mise en scène as opposed to the narrative events.
The Quays more often than not base their animations on the work of other writers and artists. Predominately taking their influence from East European art and literature, their films have been adaptations of texts by Bruno Schulz, Robert Walser, Franz Kafka and Lewis Carroll. Visually, their imagery is a hybrid constructed from the depths of art history: Ernst, Bacon, Arcimboldo, Fragonard, Bosch and Escher all make fleeting appearances within their work.
The Cabinet of Jan Svankmajer |
The Quays' next animation, This Unnameable Little Broom or Little Songs of the Chief of Hunar Louse (Being a Largely Disguised Reduction of the Epic of Gilgamesh), Tableau II (1985), relates to The Cabinet of Jan Svankmajer in that it takes some of its key visual motifs and develops them into a series of complex constructions: the use of drawers and tables as devices and as mechanisms, the transformation of meaning within an object through juxtaposition and the influence of Surrealism to create a psychosexual drama.
Unlike Svankmajer's ordered, clean white library of objects and meaning, the Quays describe Gilgamesh's kingdom as one that is “an entirely hermetic universe literally suspended out of time in a black void” (6). The pale yellow shadow-mottled walls are inscribed with calligraphic text and its seemingly vast expanse is randomly broken up by square holes from which medical hooks occasionally project. A table – a mechanism and a trap – concealing female genitalia within one of its drawers, stands at the centre of Gilgamesh's domain. High above this space are strung high-tension wires, vibrating in the wind, one caught with a broken tennis racquet.
As a symbolic construction, Gilgamesh's world is one of evil and deceit, simultaneously encoded with psychosexual tension and personal resonance for the Quays. The medical hooks, the rusting scissors, the razor sharp high-tension wires and the sound of a chainsaw all imply a castration theme, emphasised not just by the violent mechanical trap that Gilgamesh sets but also by the sequence in which he places two eggs on a slicing wicket, positioning them where his own testicles should be. Such brutal and sexually violent imagery would continue to reoccur in the brothers' films, most notably in Street of Crocodiles, where organic materials are organised into representations of male genitals, pierced with a hundred tailor's pins.
This Unnameable Little Broom |
Following This Unnameable Little Broom came the Quays' most critically admired animation, The Street of Crocodiles, an adaptation of Bruno Schulz's novel. Filled with the spectacle of insanity and decay, Schulz's novel chronicles a decent into madness. Taking this as a starting point, the film constitutes a series of beautifully complex images that may or may not have a narrative coursing through its shadows:
The Street of Crocodiles |
As if to make this connection of seeing, or the act of seeing, more apparent, the Quays place considerable emphasis on the characters' eyes. As Jonathan Romney explains, the eye, the act of seeing and the cinematic device that is the camera is central to the Quays' narratives:
Of these works, the Quays have said that they are, in some way, connected to their personal output with “just the same dark drift, basically inscrutable. It's gently mysterious” (11). Michael Atkinson describes the Stille Nacht series of music videos as “shorts [which] seem to function as working junk drawers, using up whatever the Brothers couldn't squeeze into their larger films” (12). Atkinson continues by stating that the music video Can't Go Wrong Without You (Stille Nacht IV) “may be one of the Quay's most disturbing pieces, a bizarre Easter suite with the resourceful stuffed rabbit from Stille Nacht II battling the forces of evil (a pixillated human in horns and skullface) for the possession of an egg” (13).
The Phantom Museum |
Taken as an individual work, The Phantom Museum can be viewed as much as a catalogue of the Quays' motifs as an exploration of the Wellcome collection. The visual style and latent themes of their entire output rest within each of The Phantom Museum's images: the reanimation of dead matter through construction, the intensely intimate close ups which reveal not just the aesthetics of surface and decay but also the subtleties of character and movement, the dream-like narrative enhanced by the equally dream-like imagery, all appearing against an endlessly black background. And, as ever, the disjointed dramas of life, sex and death quietly weave themselves through the abstract narratives.
As if to consolidate their status as auteurs, the Quays' commercials are as equally imbued with their personal vision. Calling this work their “pact with the devil” (14), the brothers have produced adverts for, amongst others, Coca-Cola, MTV and The PSA National Drug Council. Regardless of the client, the Quays have somehow managed to subtly work in a number of their motifs into these advertisements: using a half lit library as the setting for their Fox Sport commercial, a lone man frantically positions piles of books around the edge of a table. As the camera draws closer, the man is revealed to be a Detroit Red Wings fan and, upon the table, an ice hockey match is being played by animated constructions. As the match increases in intensity a fight breaks out between rival players, which the spectator immediately breaks up with a half bitten pencil. Engrossed in this spectacle, the man is oblivious to the girl who now stands at the table watching him watching the game. Cutting to her point of view it is revealed that the table is empty, that the match is merely being played out in the fanatic's mind.
Photographed in fading sunlight, the library is presented as an environment drained of colour and full of settling dust. The camera's movement is slow, whilst the physical action is frantic and the attention to detail, to decay, is visualised in the close ups of the animated players and the chewed pencil. Perhaps the most obvious of all the Quays' traits is the act of watching and of being watched as well as the potential insanity of the Detroit Red Wings fan.
In Absentia |
In Absentia is undeniably tragic. Intense sadness and loneliness seems to seep out of each image, recalling the moment in The Street of Crocodiles where the small plastic child tries to resurrect the Light Bulb character using a broken mirror to reflect light back into the light bulb elements.
In the ever-shifting fictional realities of the Brothers Quay, madness takes on both emotive and creative potential. For their first live-action film, the Quays adapted Robert Walser's novel Jakob von Gutten into Institute Benjamenta. Like the untimely death of Bruno Schulz, Walser's life is another gesture to the tragic within the Quays work:
Institute Benjamenta |
As a motif, the deer plays an important part to the background of the narrative as well as bringing further associations to the Quays' work. When Jacob first enters the Institute he is taken to Herr Benjamenta's office where he is seated so that the deer antlers on the office wall appear to grow out of his head. Benjamenta continues this allusion by calling him a '12 point' and measuring the space between 'his' antlers. As more of Benjamenta's office is shown, we notice that it is rife with deer remains, including a drawer of catalogued deer pellets. As Buchan explains, the repeated use of the deer motif becomes a totem, “a world of suppressed Victorian eroticism [where] they become obsessive, dark and ambiguous” (17).
As the narrative of the film progresses, it becomes apparent that Jacob may not be a prince but a perverse saviour who will release the Institute and its inhabitants from their suppression. In moments of brief confession, Jacob arouses in Lisa not love, but desire, an emotion so unfamiliar that she is unable to understand or cope with it. As she descends further into despair, Lisa simply decides to stop living. In a final moment of emotional dialogue, Lisa explains to Jacob that she is “dying from those who could have seen and held me. Dying from the emptiness of cautious and clever people.” Leaning forward she brushes her lips against Jacob's and dies. This inverted kiss of death concludes the narrative but, as with all of the Quays' adaptations of myth, is again typical inverted: As Lisa is mourned by her brother, she opens her eyes once more.
To return from the dead, to be reanimated, is the essence of the Quays' work. Taking found objects and constructing them into new forms with new meaning is only the beginning of their dark material. In their fictions narratives need not move as smoothly as we would like and nor should their imagery be as obvious. In all, these films are like their makers: identical enigmas, a life within a life, and a dream within a dream.
The Piano Tuner of Earthquakes: An Addendum
It is possible that the Quays have only ever made one film. Their second live action film, The Piano Tuner of Earthquakes (2005), satisfies this possibility in many ways. Like a true auteur, the Brothers consistently return to similar themes, similar narratives and to similar techniques, with each film not necessarily being different from but an extension of their primal narrative. For the Quays that primal narrative is tragedy, a failed attempt to escape from beautifully sinister and arcane mechanisms. When such a narrative is sited within a world constructed and populated by the lost, the lonely, the rejected and the damaged, then an intense melancholy descends and the dream becomes a complex shifting of realities: narrative is given over to imagery and story dissolves into timeless myth. It is here that The Piano Tuner of Earthquakes exists, a film that surrenders its narrative to the beauty of the image in order to create the mythical. Such is the extent of this content that the film struggles to be anything more than an extension of the Quay's concerns. This is ironic, as the surface narrative (baring resemblances to some narrative elements of Institute Benjamentia) is perhaps the most explicit of all the Quays' films – a failed attempt to rescue a beautiful woman. Given this, The Piano Tuner of Earthquakes functions as a composite of choreographed action, symbolic dialogue, exquisite animation and overt sexual imagery that maintains some narrative coherence but eventually dissolves.
Perhaps, in order to understand the Quay's intentions one must return to the opening of the film. Playing out another of their typical elements, the Quays begin The Piano Tuner of Earthquakes with a quote. It informs the viewer that what they are about to see is not real, that “These things never happen but always are”. In many ways this is true of The Piano Tuner of Earthquakes: for the Quays their film is yet to begin but it has already happened.
© James Rose, January 2004
© Addendum, November 2005
Endnotes:
- Thyrza Nichols Goodeve, “Dream Team: Thyrza Nichols Goodeve Talks with the Brothers Quay”, Artforum, April 1996, p. 84.
- Michael Atkinson, “The Night Countries of the Brothers Quay”, Film Comment, 30, September/October 1994, p. 37.
- Atkinson, p. 37.
- Suzanne H. Buchan, “The Quay Brothers: Choreographed Chiaroscuro, Enigmatic and Sublime”, Film Quarterly, Spring 1998, p. 3.
- The Brothers Quay: Volume 1, 1991, Connoisseur Video.
- S. Weiner, “The Quay Brothers' The Epic of Gilgamesh and the 'metaphysics of obscenity'” in J. Pilling (ed.), A Reader in Animation Studies, London, John Libbey & Company, 1997, p. 28.
- Weiner, p. 33.
- The Brothers Quay: Volume 1
- Jonathan Romney, “The Same Dark Drift”, Sight and Sound, March 1992, p. 25.
- Romney, 1992, p. 25.
- Romney, 1992, p. 24.
- Atkinson, p. 40.
- Atkinson, p. 41.
- Romney, 1992, p. 26.
- Goodeve, p. 118.
- Jonathan Romney, “Life's a Dream”, Sight and Sound, August 1995, p. 13.
- Buchan, p. 15.
Quay Brothers |
Filmography
All films are animated shorts, unless stated otherwise
Nocturna Artificialia (1979)
Punch & Judy (Tragical Comedy or Comical Tragedy) (1980)
Ein Brudermord (1981)
The Eternal Day of Michel de Ghelderode (1981)
Igor – Chez Pleyel – The Paris Years (1982)
Leos Janacek: Intimate Excursions (1983)
The Cabinet of Jan Svankmajer (1984)
This Unnameable Little Broom (1985)
The Street of Crocodiles (1986)
Rehearsal for Extinct Anatomies (1987)
Dramolet (Stille Nacht I) (1988)
Ex-Voto / The Pond (1989)
The Comb (From the Museum of Sleep) (1990)
De Artificiali Perspectiva or Anamorphosis (1990)
The Calligrapher Parts I, II, III (1991)
Are We Still Married? (Stille Nacht II) (1991)
Long Way Down (Look what the Cat Drug in) (1992)
Nocturna Artificialia |
Tales from the Vienna Woods (Stille Nacht III) (1992)
Can't Go Wrong Without You (Stille Nacht IV) (1993)
Institute Benjamenta (or This Dream People Call Human Life) (1994) feature
Duet - Variations for the Convalescence of 'A' (1999)
The Sandman (2000)
In Absentia (2000)
Dog Door (Stille Nacht V) (2000)
The Phantom Museum (2002)
Poor Roger (2003)
Oranges and Lemons (2003)
Green Gravel (2003)
Jenny Jones (2003)
The Piano Tuner of Earthquakes (2005)
Bibliography
Michael Atkinson, “The Night Countries of the Brothers Quay”, Film Comment, 30, September/October 1994, pp. 36–44.
Suzanne H. Buchan, “The Quay Brothers: Choreographed Chiaroscuro, Enigmatic and Sublime”, Film Quarterly, Spring 1998, pp. 2–15.
Leslie Felperin, “Institute Benjamenta”, Sight and Sound, Winter 1995, pp. 46.
Thyrza Nichols Goodeve, “Dream Team: Thyrza Nichols Goodeve Talks with the Brothers Quay”, Artforum, April 1996, pp. 82–85, 118, 126.
Laura U. Marks, “The Quays' Institute Benjamenta: An Olfactory View”, Afterimage, September/October 1997, pp.11–13.
Jonathan Romney, “The Same Dark Drift”, Sight and Sound, March 1992, pp. 24–27.
Jonathan Romney, “Life's a Dream”, Sight and Sound, August 1995, pp. 12–15.
S. Weiner, “The Quay Brothers' The Epic of Gilgamesh and the 'metaphysics of obscenity'” in J. Pilling (ed.), A Reader in Animation Studies, London, John Libbey & Company, 1997, pp. 25–37.
Articles in Senses of Cinema
Through a Glass Darkly: Interview with the Quay Brothers by André Habib
Tribute to Raymond Durgnat by The Brothers Quay
Web Resources
Zeitgeist Films | The Brothers QuayThe 'official' web presence for the Quays. Includes profiles of the Brothers and a number of their films as well as links to sites containing their commissioned works.
Shifting Realities: The Brothers Quay - Between Live Action and Animation by Suzanne Buchan
Online version of the Buchan's essay, exploring the content and context of Institute Benjamenta.
The Quay Brothers: Choreographed Chiaroscuro, Enigmatic and Sublime by Suzanne Buchan
On line version of the Buchan's essay which examines the majority of the Quays output, from Nocturna Artificialia to Institute Benjamenta.
The Phantom Museum
The official site for Henry Wellcome Collection, which features two downloadable excerpts from the Quay's The Phantom Museum commission.
Believemedia
Features downloadable adverts animated by the Quays for Fox Sports, PSA National Drug Council and Round Up Weeds.
Brothers Quay: In Absentia
Interview.
http://www.sensesofcinema.com/contents/directors/04/quay_brothers.html
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home